Hi Arthur! Thank you for taking the time to review my shot, and for putting pen to paper. I hold my hand up and accept all your points as being perfectly valid, and I welcome such critique. I have another similar shot that may have adressed some of your points I'll post it, and again I would welcome your views. Kindest regards Jim.
Hi James, I have just a few comments on an otherwise colourful and well composed shot. The horizon is uneven, it tilts right to left, the half ship on the right is very distracting, and it would have been nice if you could have got more of the sail boat's mast in the shot and more of the reflectin in the water.
0 
