|
|
|
Stephen Bivens
{K:7308} 9/23/2004
|
Tiff, Do what you do ! I love it.
|
|
|
|
|
bart soriano
{K:1660} 9/23/2004
|
The grainy effect just worked fine on this Angel but needs a bit more detail as what Karen had mentioned. But it worked better as a photo art for me. The angle of shot shows the Angel looking down joyfully. Perhaps seeing the few good people on earth.
This is your shot Tiff, your composition. No matter what "tools" you used to enhance it, it's still your art. It's simply like an empty glass. Show it to a lot of people. You will hear different & varying interpretations based on what they feel.
A good critique would always point what he/she doesn't like in the composition, what's lacking or needs improvement and better if he/she comes out with some suggestions on how to go thru with it the next time. Not just blah blah blah and drop you dead.
Go on with what you would like to shoot & compose. Continue experimenting.
Regards! - joey
|
|
|
|
|
Tiffany Woodley
{K:231} 9/23/2004
|
Thank both you and Jeff for your constructive comments.
|
|
|
|
|
Jeff Fiore
{K:11277} 9/23/2004
|
Answer: Yours, Tiffany - it was your imagination that put it all together.
|
|
|
|
karen clarke
{K:18893} 9/23/2004
|
Tiffany, definitely an interesting effect, really emphasizes the grainy feel of stone. Perhaps a bit more details would help to improve. Composition is nice.
As for the comment by Jim, if certain people don't appreciate a certain style of photography than they should move on to a style they enjoy, instead of acting immature. I could see if he had at least of added a real "constructive critique", but what he said was obviously aimed at just hurting your feelings.
Please hold his comment in disregard, and keep on experimenting~
|
|
|
|
|
Jim Webb
{K:209} 9/22/2004
|
question: whose art is it? yours? the sculptor's? or the programmer of the charcoal filter in photo editor?
|
|
|
|
|
Jeff Fiore
{K:11277} 9/22/2004
|
Very nice effect, I like it! Good job!
|
|
0 
